Monday, August 29, 2022

Judenrein

In 1973, the first Monopoly World Tournament took place at Grossinger’s Hotel in Liberty, New York. Less than a decade-and-a-half later the hotel—the Star Beet of the Borscht Belt—closed for good.


About a week-and-a-half ago, the derelict remains of the grand resort were engulfed by a great fire. Sic transit gloria mundi!


I learned of the fate of Grossinger’s remains from this report by NPR: https://www.npr.org/2022/08/19/1118549797/huge-blaze-engulfs-grossingers-hotel-inspiration-for-dirty-dancing


The headline of the article proclaimed that Grossinger’s was famous because it supposedly inspired the movie “Dirty Dancing”: 

A huge blaze engulfs Grossinger's Hotel, the location that inspired 'Dirty Dancing.' 

Three lines of the article were about the movie, but only one sentence told the reader what the hotel was all about: 

Hundreds of thousands of vacationers made their way to the Catskills to visit the spot.


But who were those vacationers? On that NPR is shtum.


The New York Times, to its shame, in the headline for its fire report also saw fit to link Grossinger’s to the same crappy movie:

Catskills Hotel That Inspired ‘Dirty Dancing’ Suffers Devastating Fire.


And the Times waited seven paragraphs to answer what NPR declined to say—that Grossinger’s was part of “a vibrant vacation scene for a primarily Jewish clientele.” 


And what did they come for?


Not to buy the deed for the Boardwalk or to pass Go and collect $200.


But for rest, relaxation, lots of good food, and great entertainment (so many comedians, singers, and actors got their start in the Borscht Belt).


It wasn’t the goyishe dirty dancers who quaffed the red stuff in the Borscht Belt. 


***


The flames that engulfed the remains of the great Grossinger’s Hotel were not as hot as I was when I read the NPR article (and later saw the Times headline). 


Here are some other headlines:

Fire hits vacant Grossinger's hotel, once a Catskills jewel that became 'Dirty Dancing' inspiration

ABC

Building at the Catskills' famed Grossinger's resort, an inspiration for "Dirty Dancing," burns down in massive fire

CBS

And in the ultimate disgrace:

Fire destroys building at Grossinger’s Catskills resort, the inspiration for ‘Dirty Dancing’

NY Jewish Week 


***



Who needs the Christian Nationalists to eliminate the Jews when a pop culture reference can make decades of a strong cultural heritage disappear?


 

Tuesday, August 23, 2022

Don't Send in the Clowns

OK, class, it’s time for a quiz.


What does this picture have to do with Shakespeare’s Hamlet?





You in the back playing with your cell phone—what do you have to say?


Oh, er, that looks like a clown—a woman clown. I don’t think that that has anything to do with Hamlet. I mean, he was a prince, right? And a guy. Not a clown, and not a woman, right?


Well now, take a look at this second picture. I ask the same question: What does this picture have to do with Shakespeare’s Hamlet?





You there, spooning yogurt into your mouth—what do you have to say?


Well [gulp], what he said. That’s a lady clown, not a prince of Denmark.


You two are half right; the first picture is from a magazine advertisement advertising magazine advertisements. It’s from 1970. The second picture is from the front cover of a DVD recording of a 2018 production of Hamlet at Shakespeare’s Globe in London. 


But maybe, on second thought, both your answers are correct. While the recording is allegedly of Shakespeare’s tragedy, one must wonder what in hell it has to do with the play Shakespeare wrote. [I leave aside for now the issue of whether a woman should play the Prince.] Why is Hamlet made up and dressed as a clown? What in the text signals that? Then again, even if there was clear reason for the Prince to be a clown, why is he dressed in white? Hamlet himself (in Act I, Scene 2) refers to his “inky cloak” and “customary suits of solemn black.” Which is a sign of his continuing mourning for his father. Is the wearing of white meant to be a vitiating or elimination of Hamlet’s deep-seated feeling? 


I have no intention of ever watching the Globe’s production to record other abominations.   


*


Classic theater and opera are unfortunately hostages to directors who harbor IDEAS. These ideas are put to work overriding the intentions of the original creator—playwright or composer/librettist.  


Simon Brett in his 1997 satirical mystery novel Sicken and So Die has landed his fourth-rate actor-hero, Charles Paris, a part in Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night. Unfortunately, the original director succumbs to food poisoning and is replaced by an avant-garde Romanian director, who has an IDEA: the cast will play the comedy nude. Except for the fact that there’s a murder, the book is wonderfully funny and absurd.


Perhaps the most famous 20th century example of a director imposing his IDEA on a Shakespearean play is the case of Peter Brooks’ production of A Midsummer Night’s Dream, which appeared in New York in 1971. Brendan Gill, in his New Yorker review, notes that 



And Clive Barnes, who raved about the production in the New York Times [“the greatest production of Shakespeare I have ever seen in my life”], wrote of “an Oberon on a trapeze, a Puck who juggles with plates or dashes across the scene on Tarzan rope or runs on stilts.” [Here is a video of some plate spinning.]  

  


All that was mind-boggling stupidity enough, but perhaps worst of all was having characters on their knees speaking Shakespeare’s great verse affectlessly.


*


Gill was “miserable” during the evening and wondered what Brooks’ intention was.



Mr. Gill, staying the course, had a stronger stomach than me; I walked out very early in the evening and went home to a welcome cup of tea. I figured if I wanted a circus, I would buy popcorn and wait for the elephants.


 

Friday, August 12, 2022

Bottoms Up!

A

Fifth

of 

Jim Beam



*


A

Fifth 

of

Johnnie Walker



*


A 

Fifth

of 

Donald Trump






Monday, August 8, 2022

Round and Round

We have the Hebrews to thank, it has been said, for giving us the belief that history is linear and not circular. It was, however, a member of the tribe, Karl Marx, who claimed that history does repeat itself: appearing first as tragedy, and then as farce.


I was never a believer in the circularity of history, whether manifesting itself as reincarnation, the transmigration of souls, or Yeats’ “A Vision,”* most prominently displayed in his great poem “The Second Coming.” However, recently, I have found reason to share Marx’s view about historical repetition, although I’m not sure that his formulation is correct, or if the reverse is true—history appears first as farce and only later as tragedy.


*


Since in the last few years I have had more spare time than I know what to do with it (yes, I know that I could engage in saving the whales or mining crypto), I have undertaken a kind of historical research by trawling the archives of The New Yorker magazine. I am on my second go-round; having begun this tour in 1940, I am now into the autumn of 1971. What has stood out most prominently this time around is that the state of the United States in the late 1960s and early 1970s was uncannily like what we face today, a half-century on.


In this blog post I have gathered together many cartoons and comments from back then which I think you will plainly recognize as distant mirror images of our own time.


*



*

*


*


*


*

Now on to the political.


*


*


*


*

2022

Former President Donald Trump called for the US Department of Education's abolition during his Saturday speech at the Conservative Political Action Conference in Dallas, Texas.

Trump told a crowd that prohibitions need to be brought in on teaching "inappropriate racial, sexual and political material" to American schoolchildren.

"If federal bureaucrats are going to push this radicalism, we should abolish the Department of Education," he continued.

https://news.yahoo.com/crowd-cheers-trump-calls-abolition-093209367.html


*



*


*


*

Philip Hamburger visited Kent, Ohio in 1971, one year after Ohio National Guardsmen murdered four Kent State students who were protesting US actions in South East Asia. Here's what one local interviewee said:


*

2022

Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.) on Saturday said “no one can convince” her that the rioters behind the Jan. 6 attack at the U.S. Capitol were not anti-fascist protesters 

https://news.yahoo.com/rep-marjorie-taylor-greene-no-193748469.html


"As another example, the sting they did involving Gretchen Whitmer was fake. Just like those who instigated January 6. It was a fake deal. Fake. It was a fake deal," Trump said. . . . 

Trump also alluded to conspiracy theories about the Capitol riot being orchestrated by FBI agents, propagated by his allies, including Ted Cruz and Fox News presenter Tucker Carlson.

https://www.businessinsider.com/trump-jan-6-riot-gretchen-whitmer-kidnap-plot-fake-cpac-2022-8


*


*

l. E. Sissman 


Review of Joe McGinniss, The Selling of the President 1968


*


And Finally:





***


*  “All things are subject to a cycle of changes, which can be regarded as bi-polar, passing from a state of objectivity to one of subjectivity before returning to objectivity again. This can be seen as a form of oscillation, or a circuit around a wheel, and divides experience into the two halves of objectivity and subjectivity.”


(Got that?)


https://www.yeatsvision.com/Overview.html#AV











 

Saturday, July 30, 2022

Top of the Tree By Hook or Crook

Really, there was no reason to be surprised at the revelation that Donald Trump wanted to award himself the Congressional Medal of Honor.

“As president, I wanted to give myself the Congressional Medal of Honor, but they wouldn’t let me do it…they said that would be inappropriate.”* 
After all, we always knew that he thought himself to be top of the tree—and would do anything to boost himself up there.


Consider his golf game. He claims to have won 20 championships.** That’s a lie, of course. What is true is that he proclaimed himself winner of 20 championships.


Rick Reilly explained Trump’s method:

Whenever he opens a new golf course, because he owns 14 and operates another five, he plays the first club champion by himself and declares that the club championship and puts his name on the wall.

But it’s usually just him and Melania in the cart and nobody else. He just makes it up.

Jack Holmes added:

Imagine owning numerous golf clubs with your name plastered all over them and still needing to have your name up on the championship plaque, even though you know it's meaningless.

But fraudulent golf championship plaques aren’t the only fakery on the walls of Trump properties. There’s also the matter of the bogus Time magazine covers.



Although Donald Trump has repeatedly appeared on the cover of Time Magazine in the last year, the company is asking that a framed cover image of Trump be taken down from the walls of several golf clubs.

That's because the cover hanging in several Trump Organization clubs is a phony, a Time spokesperson confirmed to NBC News.

The March 1, 2009, cover was first identified as fake by The Washington Post . . .*** 

(Time didn’t publish on March 1, 2009.)


*


Trump’s ego-fed self-elevation to (undeserved) top-ranking that his neediness seems to demand reminds me of an important event in European history: Napoleon’s self-crowning as Emperor in December 2, 1804 at the Cathedral of  Notre-Dame in Paris.



No, I do not equate Trump and Napoleon. One conquered most of Europe through armored might, while the other conquers golf championships by cheating and fakery.


(He once stole another golfer’s ball, claiming that the ball on the green was his, instead of the one he had shot into a water hazard.)


One was the Little Corsican; the other a little coarse man.  


***


*  https://www.thewrap.com/trump-peeved-couldnt-give-himself-medal-of-honor/


**  https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/a27431421/donald-trump-golf-cheat-club-champion-child-ball-water/


*** https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/time-asks-donald-trump-s-golf-clubs-remove-phony-magazine-n777546


Friday, July 22, 2022

Nuts and Lightning Bolts

Although you may not know it, good satire is an exceedingly rare commodity. More than ever, the creation of the ridiculous is almost impossible because of the competition it receives from reality. In the old days, if the satirist was artful, he obtained his greatest effects by exaggerating the norm in such a way that the reader became aware of its abnormality. Today the extreme is so commonplace there is little left for the satirist to do.


Robert A. Baker (1963)


“Introduction,” A Stress Analysis of A Strapless Evening Gown (And Other Essays For A Scientific Age)


*

Irony, as was pointed out in an earlier post, involves at least two separate states of awareness. The ironist—who is always insincere—has one state of awareness; he knows that his presentation is deliberately overstating what he doesn’t believe, or understating that which he does believe. The former—the overstatement—is the mode of sarcasm. The satirist, after putting forward (seemingly approvingly) the position of his opponent, then attempts to undermine it by setting it down a path of ever-increasingly absurd propositions. Hopefully, at some point, the penny drops and the opponent can no longer cling on to his belief. Reason and logic have abandoned him. Only foolishness remains. And only a fool remains with it.


*


Jovan Pulitzer is either one of the world’s greatest satirists—or a complete nut. He was identified by slate.com as either the originator or popularizer of the claim that one reason the 2020 presidential election was “stolen” from Donald Trump was that Chinese thermostats controlled US voting machines, changing Trump votes secretly into Biden ones.*


I stand in awe of such a pronouncement. It has all the earmarks of a brilliant satirical invention—specifically, a sarcastic thrust against Trumpian believers of a massive conspiracy that put the Democratic candidate into the White House.


Consider:


The statement posits a voting machine conspiracy by which Trump votes were sabotaged (which is the Trumpian position).

 

It then identifies the most outrageous possible instrument as having been used to achieve the transfer of votes—a thermostat, the device that regulates the temperature level of your house. 


Crazy enough for you? Wait!


They weren’t just any ignoble thermostats—they were CHINESE thermostats. 


Bad enough that the Chinese have been inundating the US with plastic doodads to fill the shelves of your neighborhood Dollar General emporium; now they’ve gone hightech.


Sure, the sarcasm would work if the Chinese were left out—or if, say the Germans or the Israelis were the alleged culprits. But adding the Yellow Peril—that just puts the satire over the top.


But was it satire—or was it nuttiness? As Robert Baker is quoted, at the top of the page, in 1963 “the extreme is so commonplace.” Is today any different?


*


Another vote conspiracy allegation, supposedly promulgated by a group called Nations in Action, claimed (again according to slate.com) that “an Italian defense contractor uploaded software to a satellite to switch votes from Donald Trump to Joe Biden.” 


Examining this claim, we find similarities to the thermostat mishegas:


Here, too, outrageously inappropriate technology is being used. 


Instead of the Chinese we  have the ITALIANS. The land that has given the world Michaelangelo, Sophia Loren, and linguini aglio e olio, is not, I believe, world-renowned for its satellite technology. 


The conspiracy theory is stretched to the breaking point. 


But, apparently, there’s no attempt at satire here; we’re mired in true conspiracy swampland. Nations in Action claims its goal to be “the exposure of the ‘shadow government’ that controls the world.”


(If you think all of the above is too crazy for words, White House chief of staff Mark Meadows had several government agencies investigate the thermostat and satellite claims.)


*


At which point, what should a sane person think? 


J. B. S. Haldane, the polymath scientist, said:


"My own suspicion is that the universe is not only queerer than we suppose, but queerer than we can suppose.”


I would suggest that the United States today “is not only queerer than we suppose, but queerer than we can suppose.” 


***


* https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2022/06/jan-6-roe-gas-prices-congress-skewed-priorities.html

Saturday, July 16, 2022

A Different Drum

What in my eyes made the December 2, 1967 issue of The New Yorker worthy of note?


Of the 213 covers drawn by Arthur Getz for the magazine, the December 2 one was not particularly distinguished. 



The Table of Contents didn't offer much:




The movies reviewed by Brendan Gill in “The Current Cinema”—“The Fearless Vampire Killers,” “Tender Scoundrel,” and “Lemonade Joe”—were disasters.


What caused my affection for the issue were two advertisements—one for a wristwatch and the other for a brand of Scotch whisky.


With the successful conclusion of World War II, the watch industry, freed of its obligation to supply the military, began to produce, once again, timepieces for the general public. But what selling point did the watch manufacturers emphasize to lure customers to their particular product? Thinness. For the next several decades, one could hardly escape a watch advertisement that did not extoll the timepiece’s thinness, even to the point of many manufacturers claiming the title of the thinnest.  









It was, therefore, with great pleasure that I found on page 85 the following ad for a Movado chronograph:




“The Fat Watch”! Ten dimes high! How wonderfully refreshing! 


*


The second advertisement that caught my eye was for a brand of Scotch that I had never heard of before: Hankey Bannister. Unlike the full-page Movado endeavor, the Hankey ad on page 104 occupied less than half a page. “HANKEY the bold one!” it proclaimed and added satirically, “The Scotch that makes others pale by comparison.”




What Hankey was doing was placing itself in opposition to the lemming-like procession of other distillers exhorting the public to down their “light” liquids.


Here’s Vat 69:





And King William IV:




And Ambassador (claiming to be the lightest):




And then there’s Chivas Regal, which changed its bottle color from green to clear glass five years earlier (look at us—we’re really light):




*


“There is nothing new under the sun,” according to Ecclesiastes. Well, maybe there is. But as far as advertising goes, it takes a long walk in the park before one comes across a product that eschews the clichés of the herd and marches to its own drum. And in the cases of Scotch whisky and wristwatches, if the searches for lightness and thinness were carried to their ultimate conclusions, the products would disappear altogether. 


***


Notes:


‡ Chivas earlier this year announced changes to its bottle’s shape:


Chivas has unveiled a new look for its flagship blended Scotch whisky. It is the 'biggest' redesign in Chivas’ 112-year history. Chivas 12 has undergone a redesign of its bottle, label and pack. . . .The redesign is aimed to see the Chivas 12 bottle reshaped and elongated to stand taller and prouder, while still retaining its recognisable rounded shoulders.


https://www.afaqs.com/design-digest/chivas-12-undergoes-first-big-packaging-redesign-in-112-years


‡ I Googled Hankey Bannister to see if that brand is still in existence. It is. But, alas, on its website it says,

Messrs Hankey and Bannister present their Original blend of fine and rare Scotch whiskies.  Hand selected for quality and crafted with care to create a smooth, light and perfectly balanced blend renowned in society for over 250 Years.


I guess it’s too much to ask for a brand to hold out against a tide for over half a century.